The Undifferentiated Human
From Horizontal to Vertical Life
When we emerge from the womb we are very vulnerable for the human organism is immature and helpless and depends completely on its mother. If the 40 weeks in utero was the development of embryo to fetus to infant, then the next few years illustrates the process yet again. The first eight or nine months of life the human child lacks the ability to be at any level, independent. If we were to look at this as part of a holon or holarchy then this child illustrates an undifferentiated state. It infers that the parts that have created it are not yet acting as interdependent holons or complete entities within the organism. The infant is functional– it lives–but it is not independent of its primary host, for although we are unattached from our uterine dependence on our mother’s, we may still remain as if psychically attached to our mothers, and certainly for our immediate survival we require constant attention. Graphically you could think of the child having a material self–a blueprint–a physiological self (systems and organs) with a partially developed mammalian self (gender, lungs, joints and muscles; locomotive resource) and incomplete human self (neocortex).
- “The child looks like me (or his father)" – genetic or material self
- "It is whole and complete–we counted the toes and fingers, he can hear, has startle reflexes, (scored 9 on the Apgar scale)– material integrity, "and cries, eats, poos and pees" – physiological or vegetal self),
- "She does sleep and digest its food (flexibility), and she turns her head, hears my voice, looks at me (us), has four limbs, and wriggles around" – animal self (instincts) and reflectiveness (vision, seeing)
- "and smiles and is beginning to respond (human-animal)”.
The infant is undifferentiated. It now goes through an intense period of cortical development, integration of its lower and higher centers, becomes neurological competent (integrity) and begins to interact with the outside world, moves from wriggling its limbs, to turning over, begins to crawl, stand and fall copying its peers and all that is going on around it. It is emergent.
As the child interacts with its environment, it begins to differentiate how it feels, and starts to have different emotive-reactive responses to communicate its needs in its non-language period. Its voice is the cry, the whimper, the pout, the aggrieved, the wounded, the hurt as well as the giggle and laughter as it interacts with the mother and others. It differentiates too through what it wants to eat, or not eat, when it wants to go to bed, sleep or be put down to rest or farmed out to the provider or nanny. It starts to emerge out of history and emerge into an emotional world which it begins to sift through ‘responses’ so that it can interact with its environment.
We send the child off to school, as it has outgrown its childhood environment, and is ready for another adventure, one of self autonomy and discovery. This is the animal phase where the child now interacts with others, with different tribes and groups (if its lucky) and begins to discover self through others.
The bantu word UBUNTU as described by Archbishop Desmond Tutu in 2008:
The development of this humanist or ethical model is our dynamic interaction with others. This is the training between instincts, desires and needs, historical and unseen genes and memes trying to promote their dominance or power over the organism. This phase can last a long time (“he’s never grown up, he’s always in survival mode, he’s always after the girls, she’s a little fox, out for what she can get”), and may last a lifetime. Generally speaking we mark this movement from animal to human as another rite of passage. This is often the school matriculation or University graduation; where someone is honored for their learning and erudition, which has paved their way towards being a meaningful and valuable contribution towards humanity.
Undifferentiated animal-human or human-animal
If we look at old mythologies and stories, we will note that often the old Greek myths (for example) were peppered with fantastical beasts; half-human half-animal or an amalgam of several forms. These characterise levels of human development, very cleverly masking the idea that we are looking at rather intimate and personal images of our own natures, when we are in this developing yet undifferentiated state. The undifferentiated state is our de facto situation; we are always developing from form to form, and in-between morphing with one realm into the other, so that the lower realm still has exaggerated influence over the realm above.
Minotaur - human-animal
The minotaur is a human with a bull-like head. The human and animal components are interchanged; as if the capacity to be reflective–the bridge between an instinctual reactive survival-based life and a cognitive reflective life–a human quality are juxtaposed. The human is unable to pause, and is always reactive, reflexive, unpredictable; a bull in the china shop. There is no capacity for the person to fly, to be imaginative, to go beyond the known–as the animal instincts drive the oranism.
Pan – the human-animal
We grow into a Pan, when our instinctual nature is still morphed and intimate with the human self it retains some of the characteristics of the goat. A satyr is simply the youthful aspect of this undifferentiated human. Pan's life (flexibility) is in his rhythmical pan-pipes made out of the reeds of a riverbed, and it is with these lilting melodic sounds he seduces all around him. The hedonist, bon vivant, the ladies man, the men and women (her animus) whose carnal and gourmet needs are met by this undifferentiated nature. Pan is a developing human, and yet it takes time to emerge out of this nature–we see it all round us when we observe how many people are caught having extramarital affairs, have a dark side to their passions and needs.
Mermaid – the Feeling-human
The mermaid represents the human who has not yet separated from their feelings, which although beneath their human nature–the tail–influences their humanity. These are people, rather idealistic, often not grounded (they live in their feelings, and metaphorically are aquatic, and so do not live on terra firma) indeed, if the stories are correct, they may even lose their voice when they do come on land. The width and breadth of their feeling nature is huge, so you will see these as people who are immersed in their feelings, emotions. They support causes which depend on empathy, are in fact rather important in society because they carry the emotions and feelings of the planet. However when they unable to come on land, that is differentiate or separate from they emotions– may never really accomplish their personal goals albeit may be the catalyst for others to finish the task.
There are numerous examples of undifferentiated humans, all of which tell the ancient story of our evolution as a human from our material original state to one that is a noble creature; from a one storied house to a five storied house or building. [NB This has no bearing at all, on our economic or social status but our inner state.]
All of us human go through these stages, not necessarily any of those characterized above, but stages where our basic self has yet to separate and be able to operate in an autonomous way from that which lies below. The bridges of the caduceus –Integrity, Flexibility, reflectiveness and Surender are the tools, resources, assets, qualities , virtues tax enable us to move and separate from the dominant self (below) and which allow us to become more than who we were. At all times , we are human, but governed by our lesser selves, and as we develop these become allies in our development.